Oct. 8, 2025

The Trouble with Jesus: From Doubt to Faith | Constance Hastings | 028

The Trouble with Jesus: From Doubt to Faith | Constance Hastings | 028
Coincidence or God?
The Trouble with Jesus: From Doubt to Faith | Constance Hastings | 028

In this inspiring conversation, Mick Wienholt sits down with author and counselor Constance Hastings to explore doubt within faith. Constance shares how God led her through unexpected twists—from growing up in a non-religious family, to resisting church membership for 20 years, to finally surrendering her life and calling to ministry.

She opens up about her struggles with doubt, control, and suffering, and how those challenges ultimately revealed a deeper purpose: serving others and pointing them to Christ. Her book, The Trouble with Jesus: Considerations Before You Walk Away, invites both believers and skeptics to wrestle honestly with their questions and discover hope in Jesus.

👉 In this episode, you’ll hear about:

- Why Constance resisted joining the church—and what changed everything

- How she transitioned from teaching into faith-based counseling

- Wrestling with doubts about suffering, prayer, and God’s will

- The surprising way God gave her purpose through writing her book

👉 If you’ve ever struggled with doubt, wondered about God’s plan, or longed to discover your true purpose, this story will encourage and challenge you.

📖 Learn more about Constance and her book: https://www.constancehastings.com


✦ Share this episode with someone who needs encouragement today


When You Look Links

YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@WhenYouLookShow

Be a Guest https://www.whenyoulook.com/beaguest

Website https://www.whenyoulook.com/

Instagram https://www.instagram.com/whenyoulookshow/

Facebook https://www.facebook.com/whenyoulookshow/


Chapters

0:24 - Meet Constance

0:47 - Constance's Early Years

5:03 - Getting Into Counseling

7:56 - Life Turned Upside Down

10:03 - Navigating Challenges As A Counselor

12:24 - Directed to Write a Book

14:41 - Book Overview

19:38 - Skeptics Point of View

21:22 - Lingering Questions

24:50 - Doubt vs. Not Believing

27:41 - What Are Skeptics Looking For?

33:39 - Coincidence or God?

35:40 - How Has Your Life Changed?

37:31 - Constance's Contact Info

0:00 I have purpose. I have a reason to get up, I have a place in which to serve. I have people who've come into my life that I never would have known otherwise, and that's been the biggest difference. Welcome to When You Look, where ordinary people share their extraordinary experiences and you get to decide was it coincidence or God? Constance, Welcome to When You Look. So Great to have you on the show. It's great to be here, Nick. Well, we're excited to have a wonderful conversation, hear about the book that you have written, but also your story. So let's jump into all of that after we learn a little bit more about you.

0:44 So tell us a little bit about yourself. Well, Nick, sometimes I say I shouldn't be where I am today. And it's it started early in life. My family was not particularly religious. However, it was during the time of desegregation. My parents, not wanting me to be caught up in that, decided to send me to a private school. And right down the street there was a small independent Christian School that wasn't very expensive and they felt I would be safe there. So that's where they sent me. Oh, I was very safe there, So safe that God grabbed me. And there in the love of those teachers, I met my Lord and Savior.

1:33 And that stayed with me, even though, as I said, I was in a family, which was not one that I, I mean, it was very loving family and and, you know, supportive, but they just didn't quite understand why it was that I was doing so well. Let's say in Bible study, I excelled. There were kids in the class whose parents were pastors and missionaries. My dad owned a bar and I won the Bible be twice. So in that regard, God just kept his hand on me in high school and in college. I did not though, have a supportive family or even a church family to hold me, but those feet, they still were part of that and still kept me in God's hand.

2:26 When I graduated from college, the only job I could get teaching at the time was in a school where my department chair was also the son of a pastor. And we began dating. And of course, he wanted me to go to church with him, which I did and found that I knew more about the Bible and I knew the hymns better than anybody else in the church. However, I didn't want to join the church. And this went on for 20 years. I would be asked by pastors and other people, why did you join the church? It's like, why? You know, I look around here and I see people who just come because it's, you know, a social thing to do or a place to drop their kids and things like that.

3:15 And they didn't have a real full understanding in life in Jesus Christ. And I wanted to put my name on that kind of a list that thank you. But it was during Lent. And at that time, I thought what I would do is give up music for that period. Now I'm the kind who always has music on, but I thought I'd just see in the silence if God had anything to say. And God said, join your church. And I'm like, why? Well, this went back and forth for several weeks and it was during Holy Week almost to up to actually Good Friday that God said during your church. And then I read that when Jesus went before Pilate, Pilate said to him, you're leaders, you're the chief priests have brought you here.

4:16 And I thought if Jesus would not walk away from his church, but stayed there, taught in the temple and in the synagogues and ministered to people from that place, how could I refuse to join mine? And so I did. And I thought that the Holy Spirit would get off my back and I could go on and live my life as I thought, as I thought I should. At the time I was teaching at a Community College. I always wore a cross to teach in. I would pray with my students not only for their academic success, but also in personal ways. And I thought I was serving God pretty well. That should be enough as I was.

5:04 Again, the Holy Spirit came and said, no, I want you to be going to more committed, formal ministry. And I'm thinking you got to be kidding. You have got to be kidding. I cannot see myself working in a church and certainly not in the Pasco ministry. But that that wouldn't go away. And I went to my pastor and talked and said, you know, this doesn't make sense. And they said, OK, but we got to tell you something. At that time it was a Methodist Church and there was being formed what was an order of Deacon who would have a ministry between the church and the world and where I was teaching.

5:46 There also was a master's degree program in counseling. And the day I realized it, I was absolutely trembling and I knew that my call would be to become trained as a mental health counselor, to enter a faith-based practice and serve my church in that way. And that's exactly what happened. Again, not my plan, not where I thought it was headed, not what I even wanted, but where God was leading me. I had that practice for 18 years and I was working alongside a church and my husband was there and we were teaching and leading small groups and all those kinds of things that again, God should be happy with this.

6:33 But as it was, I had been given and not because I wanted to, but then given a book to write. But ministry kept me so busy. I never had the time to actually sit down and focus my husband. My son came to me and said, we want you to retire and move closer to where our son lived. And I said, OK, I'll do that. But you've got to give me time and space to write this book, which they did. And that became the trouble with Jesus considerations before you walk away. That process of writing a book, that process of speaking about it and speaking into places again where I never would go otherwise is how God has led me. Now you could say that a lot of this was based upon my own choice, and I do believe God gives us choice. But those choices were such that they were made unmistakably in faith, most of the time not knowing where I was going but where God was waiting.

7:39 That, in short, is how I came to be here. Yeah. Wow. Constance, thank you for giving us all of that back story. I want to explore a bunch of this a little bit more, and then we'll go into a bit more about the book because I think we've got some great discussion there as well. But you talked about, as the master's program became evident to you, this sort of clarity, but also this trembling. Tell us a little bit more about that. I knew that taking this step would turn my life upside down. I had thought that my place in life was to be a teacher.

8:22 And again, it was often to the disadvantage. And I just that's that's just where I was so much in a place of comfort. What happened was when I went into counseling, I lost that comfort. As a teacher, I excelled, but as a counselor, I had such a deep, steep learning curve and so dependent upon God as I would meet my clients and in the the troubles and the trauma that they had. And it wasn't a comfortable place for me for a very, very long time. I had a lot of insecurities and again, knowing that entering into this kind of life in ministry that my, my income would be impacted and I lost probably about $40,000 in salary in six weeks, you know, by by entering into that.

9:25 And yet I'm, I just have to say that God's provision has been there all the way through. I lack for nothing. And not just my needs, but you know, some of my desires of comfort in life have have all been met. Now, do I, you know, do I live in luxury and lavishness and all that? No. But I'm, you know, I tell people when I talk about this, do I look like I'm hurting? I'm not God's provision. God's grace is all upon me. Yeah, wow. Praise God. Thanks for kind of breaking that down for us. But you talked about the insecurities, the steep learning curve.

10:06 You were in counseling for 18 years. How did you navigate all of that? As I said, it was very much depended upon where where God was leading me and I connected with a faith-based counseling agency that would allow counselors to work out of churches. We didn't have a central office, so to speak. I so I had that, that support that supervision within that group. But I there was a place of independence and basically I had to work as a spiritual entrepreneur in that way.

10:50 And the the fears would would come again in the insecurities of not feeling totally confident or competent. Then again, when you sit, you know, across the table, you know, in chairs with people who are very, very much in pain, you really are looking into that, the depth of that. And you realize that sometimes that you don't have anything to give them. But your presence and not having all of the answers was, was something that I had to accept.

11:31 And again, given, sometimes I would tell people, I know where you are. I give you my faith and that was the best that I could give them in the grace of God. Other times I would tell people if I could fix your problems, I would be a very rich woman. So fixing problems wasn't my call, but rather, again, to walk in those journeys with them and to listen to them. And yeah, I I would of course make suggestions as to what they could do, but to support, encourage, and to give them that confidence in nothing else that God's love would never, ever leave them.

12:19 Yeah, I'm right on. That's very, very cool. Well, one of the things you mentioned a few moments ago was that you were given a book to write. Tell us not yet about the book, but how, how or what? What gets you to the point of your saying I was given this? Tell us more about that. I was working in a church, but down the street was another church and the women of that church asked me to do a Saturday morning Bible study, a mini retreat kind of thing, which I agreed to do. Fortunately, they gave me several months to think and plan for it. I knew these women, they were smart, professional leaders, and I wanted something that would have a good impact on them from the Spirit of God.

13:15 So I started searching for what that would be. Now, Nick, you may know there are 66 books in the Bible and I could not find one message. I'm getting frustrated. And it's like, what is going on here? What do you want me to do? And one day I just looked up and I said, the troubles with Jesus. Oh, and I sat down, I started an outline. I started fleshing it out. I was able to structure it for that particular morning and it was well received. Went back to my home church, did it again, well received. And then before I knew it, I was like, oh, this is a book. This is a what you want me to do. This is going to be a book someday. So that's what I mean when I say I was given the book. I again, I had no intention to write a book to do anything like that.

14:19 Now, granted, I have a degree in English. I taught English for 25 years. I've read a lot of great literature. I know all of that, but never had that desire to actually do it until God said you're going to do it. And this is my story. Yeah, my story, man, Praise God. Well, tell us a little bit about the book and then we'll get into some conversation about some of those elements. So give us an overview of it. I'm always asked this question, so I'll just put this out there right now. People often want to know the trouble with Jesus. Do you have a problem with God? I say I don't have a problem with God, at least no more than most people do. But in that it is a book that is written first for the doubter or the skeptic.

15:15 It has a voice in it that continually challenges the narration of Jesus story. And it's sarcastic and it's questioning. And there is at times an interplay between this voice and the narration. It, it, it is the voice that is a commentary on what the is playing out in the action. And that's how it was, it was meant and how it was meant to be. Now, in the narration, the trouble with Jesus is Jesus was born into trouble. Yeah. You, you, you take away all the fairy dust out of the Christmas story and you've got, I hear this couple, they're technically not married. She's pregnant.

16:06 The government steps in and says late in her pregnancy, you need to go to this place where your husband's family's from that was about 70 miles away. They arrived, no place to stay. She has this baby in a barn. And, you know, while she's there, that very night, they get stormed with these shepherds that come in out of the fields and they're all excited. And then the next thing you know, it was some time later, but her husband gets a word from God that they need to get out of there because Herod is going to come.

16:47 And that story, that Christmas story actually ends with the slaughter of the baby boys in Bethlehem. And that's what happens when Jesus comes. There's going to be trouble. Things are going to happen not as we want but as they do in life and the world throws the worst of itself at us. In Jesus ministry he met with a lot of trouble. He was always tangling with the the Pharisees and healing on the Sabbath and you know those kinds of things. And other people were pushing for him to do what they wanted him to do.

17:29 We remember in the story with Mary and Martha, after they had lost their brother Lazarus, Jesus delays coming. And when he does, Lazarus has already passed away. Martha meets him. And the first thing that Martha says to him is, Lord, if you had been here, my brother would not have died. And you can hear in that there's a manipulation and there's challenge and there's, you know, blaming him. And this is what Jesus was met with time and time again. We know that in the end of that story, when Jesus goes to the tomb in which Lazarus is buried, there's the shortest verse of the Bible.

18:12 Jesus wept. But if you go back and you look into the Greek translation there, it means that Jesus was very angry and he had this kind of anger mixed with grief. And we do know that grief does entail anger to some point. But part of his anger was he was being pushed to be who people wanted him to be and not the Messiah who would come not to change the situation of their lives and be that Messiah who would drive out the Romans and raise them back to the Kingdom that David had, but rather than the Messiah who would come and change hearts. So Jesus had all kinds of trouble like that which all converged at his crucifixion.

19:01 But in his resurrection he overcame the worst that the world could throw at him. He overcame that trouble and He lives so that we can live in the grace that He affords us and be able to overcome not only the troubles that we have in our lives, but to meet the world in its trouble as well. Yeah, thanks. Wow, what a what a neat overview and looking at things a little bit differently when, as you said, you remove the fairy dust from certain stories. So really, really appreciate that. Why did you decide to write it from the point of view, or at least bringing the voice in of a skeptic?

19:46 As I said, I taught for 25 years and this was in public education as well as an 18 year practice in the in counseling. And I've heard those voices, those, those are voices that are very prevalent and challenging. And so when I started to use that voice, you know, God brought this back to me, however. When I went to have the manuscript edited, I deliberately looked for an editor who would act as that skeptic, that doubter, and would read from that perspective. And I asked her, I said, when you read this, I want you to read this and tell me if this voice sounds true to you. And having completed the manuscript, she said, yes, it does, except in the latter chapters. There are some parts in the narration which I think sounds like that doubter.

20:47 And I went, Oh my goodness, those are my doubts now. Those are my questions. And I had to go back. And we buy some of that. But the truth is we all have within us those questions, those doubts. And and that does lead, you know, in a life that is truly honest and following Jesus Christ, that there there is that tension in our faith that we have to recognize and wrestle with often. Yeah, I track with you on that for sure. Give us a sense for what are some of those lingering questions that long time believers have that create some degree, perhaps of doubt for them? Suffering is a big part of that.

21:38 You know, you look at physical suffering, there is not a family, not a single family that doesn't have an experience with cancer in some form. I mean, that is just so prevalent. We all know that when that diagnosis comes, that life is going to be changed in so many ways. Thank God, you know, there have been advances to help with the healing of that. But him, why, why, why doesn't this go away? Why, why are so many people affected and and afflicted by it? In my own family, my father-in-law was, as I said, a pastor and he was stricken with Parkinson's disease, which actually it was when he was in his 40s and he had to leave the ministry.

22:29 And here was a man who was very dedicated to God and his ministry was talented, people loved him, but he had to, he actually, the story goes, the tremors took over one day when he was in the pulpit and it had to be carried from the pulpit back to the Parsonage across the street. And he never went back again. 38 years. He lived with that and suffering and my mother-in-law took took care of him. But you know, many people would say to us, why did God do this? Why did you have to suffer like this? So suffering is part of it. Then there is, of course, the culture, the society who would drag up all kinds of questions and criticisms of Christians and, and bring those out. And yeah, that, that's hard to see sometimes as well. I sometimes even to the point of having to separate what people have seen in the church to who God is in Jesus Christ. And, and that's, that's a big leap for a lot of people. I, I can't say I blame them.

23:45 I can't say it's not real, but it's there. So those kinds of things from, from our culture. The other part, of course, are the voices. You don't have to go to church. You don't have to be part of this. You know, you don't have to give your money. You can live your life you want and as long as you're a good person, God will be OK with it. So the lies that people here as well and all of this we are in a battle in in a real way to check that the narrative that's out there. And one person the one time gave me real encouragement in the book and he said, if you can move the needle just to where it points just to Jesus, that is where God can move and take over.

24:41 And that's pretty much been my prayer for this book. Yeah, well that certainly would be life changing for so many people. Constance define for us the difference between doubt and not believing. As I said, we all have doubts. I'm I'm giving my doubt when I pray. I believe God can. And like most people, I have a lot to pray for in my family, within my my church, the fellowship there, you know, for, for our nation and the world there, there's a lot to pray for. My doubt comes when it's not that I don't believe that God can, but will God.

25:38 Now, when I pray for the family member, you know, I say God. And this is for salvation. Yeah. Think about what you did for Paul. You, you struck him blind and spoke to him audibly. You know, why can't you do half of that for at least this person? And you know, it's maybe it, it sounds ridiculous, but that's what I know it's going to take, it's going to take an experience of God. And there have been many opportunities and experiences of God this person could have had like continually closes their eyes to it. And I just have to stay there on my knees praying for that. And that's that's where I think Christians sometimes have have their doubts.

26:33 What does give me encouragement is if you believe in the physical resurrection of Jesus Christ, then you can believe everything that God said he did and every promise and what God says he will do. And, and that's where I stay. I don't know how, I don't know when, I don't know if I'll live long enough to see it. But that's where I stay in that hope and promise that Jesus Christ brought to us from the cross through the grave to the empty tomb. Wow, man, that's really enlightening.

27:14 You essentially just described if I can, if I can believe this one time, then I can as a result believe the rest of the times, believe all of the other things. And I think it's a really cogent way to process all of that. So thank you. Thank you for that. In your experience, teaching, counseling, etcetera, what is it that you have heard from skeptics that aren't yet Christians? That they have doubt, wonder, disbelief, whatever it might be about Christianity? What are they looking for?

28:02 A lot of people are interested in other beliefs or faith traditions where they they are the ones in control and doing what they think should take them to God. A man one time said, I believe it was in India, there was a very, very poor village, but the people were very faithful in going to the local temple and giving a large portion of their income, believing that that would then when they passed, take them into karma or heaven or something like that. And I spoke to him and I said that that's the distinction with Christianity. It's not that we go to God, but God in Jesus Christ has come to us.

28:55 And what that does then is it takes away this system of my my control. When I talk to skeptics or doubters, I often hear in them, and this is part of my counseling voice of their past experiences at which show me that they want control over what has happened to them now. Control is huge for all of us. We like to have a measure of control. You think about when a baby is born, a baby can do nothing but cry, but that is his or her system of getting control and getting his or her needs met.

29:41 As we grow, we learn how to negotiate for for our needs and the things that we want in life. We, we know that certain choices will bring us certain rewards and all of that is based on this need for control. But Christianity asks that you give out all to God. You know, and you heard the story in my life. I have no intentions of going into ministry, writing a book or whatever. You know, it's like I said, none of this was my idea. But there have been so many places where we call them to do that. And that's, that's I believe, the biggest obstacle that people have to know that there's going to come a time when in our facing what Jesus Christ did on the cross, that we have to let all of that fall away and give it to God and let God do with it what he will.

30:39 But as I said, there, there have been so many things that I've seen in my life and it in my life and in others where the blessings just pour out and we are blessed to be a blessing. And when we do that, and when we're faithful to it, God returns it in many, many ways. Yeah, wow. Thanks for illuminating control and I, I think you're spot on with that. I certainly have earlier parts of my life where 100% it was about me and me being in control. And it's pride and ego that drives that so often, certainly for me and for most other folks.

31:22 So I track with you on so much of that. The Holy Spirit, I'll just add here briefly gave me a, a, a, a wonderful bit of insight a number of years ago where he shared with me very clearly that because I was created, I was no longer central in my life, but instead I was subject to in my life. And by God's grace, that became clear for me, you know what I mean. And, and as a result of that, I was able to begin to have completely different prayers and completely different conversations with God where it, it, it went from my list of will you please do this stuff for me? Will you answer these prayers?

32:08 God sort of the genie in the bottle type of God. And instead my prayers turn to OK, your will be done. What is that will? What do you want me to do? Thy will be done as the hardest prayer to honestly pray. And I refer to the desire for a genie in the in in the bottle to wanting God to be the divine fixer and you know, fix God, fix my problems. And if you don't fix my problems then I'm not going to have anything to do. With you, yeah, yeah. And I think you like you suggested, I mean, so many people have that desire, even sitting, you know, on the couch in the counseling session, right? They, they're, they're there for the pain to be taken away and for the problem to be solved.

33:01 So really track with you on all of that. Well, you have walked us through a lifetime ultimately, obviously up until sort of today, which includes where you ended up going to school and why all the way through to various different things of not not anticipating, moving from teaching into ministry and into counseling. And so I think, you know, as we kind of round a lot of these conversations out, we get to the questions of was all of that coincidence in the series of events or was it God? So, Constance, coincidence or God? The book's subtitle to The Trouble with Jesus is Considerations Before You Walk Away. We think we can walk away, but I want to remind you of things like the the rich ruler And when Jesus said to him, sell all you have and take the money and give it to the poor, he, Jesus was filled with such love and compassion for this man. And yet the man turned around and walked away and Jesus watched him walk.

34:22 He didn't follow him. He didn't try to negotiate. He didn't say, hey man, you know, let's he let him walk away. And yet that love stayed there. That and that's what I think. Never, we never, ever walk away from that grace that comes to us, even when we think we can just shut the door on this and not have anything to do with it. And yet God will follow us and follow us, you know, for as long as our soul exists to call us to Him and to answer that question. You know, when Jesus said I am the resurrection of life, Do you believe this? To answer that question and be affirmative. Yeah, so I don't want to put words in your mouth, but it sounds like you see that all of which is transpired has ultimately been God with his hand on you. Oh.

35:19 And his yeah, the Holy Spirit with his hand on my throat, yeah, God will do that too. Sometimes less gentle than others, but again. Yeah, sort of. Whatever it takes to get our attention. Absolutely, Absolutely. Wow. Well, tell us in sort of closing here, how has your life changed through all of this? I, I've, I've been blessed. My marriage is a blessing. You know, my husband and I, we're, we're A-Team within our church and the ministries and, you know, when we teach, we play off one another and that, that's been a beauty. Our son is also married to a wonderful woman. They're very faithful in their participation in their church and in the giving and being very generous in that. He has a strong belief and he's willing to speak to it at any time.

36:26 And yeah, as far as the provisions of our life, as I said, we have all we need and, you know, measure of enjoyment in that. But most important is that God has given me purpose. And you would think somewhere along the line that all this should fall away and that, you know, I should just have life to live, but I don't. I have purpose. I have a reason to get up. I have a place in which to serve. I have people who've come into my life that I never would have known otherwise. And that's been the biggest difference. I, I understand that that purpose, in whatever way, whether it's noticeable like as it is through ministry, or whether it's something that's private, just known to me and maybe my family, that purpose will always be upon me and that purpose is to serve my Lord.

37:25 Wow, man, thanks for sharing. That purpose being very powerful. Well, Constance, tell us about how we can get the book or learn more about the book. Where can we also stay in touch with you? The the best way is through my website constanthastings.com and let me tell you about that. The website is actually a blog that is a companion to the book. It has in a 10 minute read that voice of the skeptic in there, but deals with a very specific gospel passage of Jesus Christ. So you can go through and and and read that alongside the book book book of courses in a broader scale. And you can subscribe to that blog. And if you subscribe to the blog, there's a pop up there on the website and you can receive a link and a promo code where you can get the book at 20% off, plus a free digital copy of the book that the publisher provides so that that's available as well.

38:31 And again, through my website, you can contact me, you know, through through the e-mail on the on our website. And I'd be glad to talk about your troubles with Jesus. The book also is available. Let me say this, anywhere that you love to buy books, you know, if you don't want to do the online retail thing, go to your local bookstore. And I say that because online retailers, you know, the book is shipped from someplace. It's put into an envelope, label stamped on it in the mail, gone. But in a bookstore, somebody has to open that box, take the books out, hold them in their hands, shelve them. People come by, they look at it, they, you know, read through it. It has so much more exposure.

39:21 And that can be available to more people than even just the one who buys the book. Yeah, awesome. Well, thanks for outlining all of that, Constance hastings.com. And we'll make sure that we link all of that in the description for this episode. It's been a real pleasure having you on. Thank you so much for telling your story. And then also illuminating a lot of the things that the skeptic voice as well as the real skeptic have wondered about and how to also work through some of that. So really appreciate having you on when you look. Thank you a bunch. Thank you. Was it coincidence or God?

40:07 You decide for yourself, but I believe you just heard a story for His glory. When You Look is powered by stories just like this and yours could be next. Go to whenyoulook.com/be a guest or use the link in the description below. Drop us a comment and share this episode with somebody that needs it. Until next time, thanks a bunch for listening and watching, and God bless.